The Preakness is held every third Saturday of May at the Pimlico Race Track. Like all of the Triple Crown Races, it has it's own signature cocktail and that is the Black Eyed Susan, traditionally a vodka and citrus drink.

Named after the long-standing tradition of presenting the winner of the Preakness with a blanket of Black-Eyed Susans, which is draped across the shoulders of the winning horse, this seriously maligned drink has changed recipes over the years, much like the Belmont Stakes cocktail. Rob Kasper of the Baltimore Sun said “like a racehorse that keeps changing jockeys, the Susan has changed recipes.”

From the original vodka, rum, triple sec, orange and pineapple juice version, the Susan has been served up as recipes that added peach schnapps or a shot of bourbon and even a splash of Elderflower liqueur. It all seems to depend on the bartender or which booze is sponsoring the race each year. Orange juice is a constant, while pineapple juice slips in every once in awhile. Even grapefruit juice  was added at one time.

I've done my own cocktail versions for the Kentucky Derby as well as the above mentioned Belmont Stakes and, since no one seems to be able to make up their mind on the Black Eyed Susan, I figured I was well within my rights to toss my own recipe into the race!

Originally the cocktail started out with vodka and rum, then dropped the rum when vodka was having it's heyday at the turn of the millennium,  then whiskey snuck in and sort of stuck along with the whiskey sponsor. Despite prevailing tradition, I'm just not into the vodka for this one. With the fruit juices I really want some alcohol with some muscle and a little age on it, so I'm going with rye and rum, both of which play very well with the pineapple and the orange. I also added a dash of bitters to cut the sweetness I've included with the coconut honey.


2 Oz. Templeton Rye Whiskey
1/4 Oz. Diplomatico Rum
3 Oz. Pineapple juice
1/2 Oz. Lime Juice
1 Oz. Orange Juice
1 Tablespoon of Honey Ridge Farms Honey Cremé Coconut
1 Tablespoon of hot water
2 Dashes Grapefruit Bitters
Lots of Crushed Ice

Garnish: Mandarin Orange Sections, Pineapple Chunks, Luxardo Maraschino Cherries and a Lime Slice.
(An edible yellow flower, like a  calendula, is a really nice touch, if you can get a hold of them, mine are still in sprout stage. I was unable to find out if Black Eyed Susans are edible in any way, if anyone knows leave a comment.)

Tools: Biodegradable Paper Straws, Bee Swizzle Stick (got my cute bee one from The Swizzle Stick Shop.)

Glass: Collins

Add the hot water to the Honey Cremé Coconut in the glass and mix well.
Fill the Collins glass with crushed ice.
Pour the in the rye, rum, pineapple, orange and lime juices then stir to chill.
(You can shake the ingredients with ice in a shaker if you prefer.)
Pile on the fruit garnishes (and an
 edible flower if you have one), add a fun swizzle stick, a straw and serve.


If you prefer to go with a more traditional horse race cocktail, here are a few of my variations on the Mint Julep.

Updated 5-2021

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...